The Technical Evolution of Racing Games: From Vector Graphics to Polygons
I get what it takes to send code out on constrained hardware. I know the impossible optimisations you need to develop a game that has some sort of responsiveness when you’re limited by kilobytes of memory and a CPU that’s clocked at single-digit megahertz. Racing games offer the ideal way to see the technical development of the 80s and 90s since each generation had to solve exactly the same basic issue; how can you make speed seem real on hardware that is essentially constrained?
Racing games developed from simple arcade vector graphics in the 80s to fully three-dimensional polygon rendering in the 90s. Each development was not an incremental update. Rather, it was a complete rethink of how to bring the sensation of speed to the limits of the available hardware. This ranking recognises both commercial success and technical accomplishment; the best racing games were the ones that knew their hardware well and were able to push it farther than anyone ever believed possible.
1. Super Mario Kart (SNES, 1992) – The Genre Creator with Four-Player Splitscreen
Super Mario Kart came to market in Japan on August 27, 1992, in North America on September 1, 1992, and in Europe on January 21, 1993. This is the game that established the whole genre of kart racing. Before Super Mario Kart, there were racing games. There were Mario games. Combining those two with four-player splitscreen multiplayer was the innovation that made everything else irrelevant.
The technical accomplishment behind Super Mario Kart is frequently underestimated. The SNES had a Ricoh 5A22 CPU that ran at 3.58 MHz with 128 KB of primary RAM and 64 KB of video RAM. To produce four-player splitscreen racing on that hardware was an extraordinary accomplishment of engineering. Each player received a quarter of the screen. The courses had to be built in such a manner that four simultaneous viewpoints made sense. The collision detection had to take into account four racers travelling at different velocities. The power-up system had to provide fairness among the four players.
Super Mario Kart went on to sell 8.76 million units worldwide, making it the 4th best-selling game for the SNES. In Europe, it was the #1 seller in Q1 1993 and it generated greater than 250,000 units in the UK. While Super Mario Kart was simply another highly successful racing game, it was a phenomenon that demonstrated the massive potential for multiplayer racing in terms of consumer purchasing.
Super Mario Kart offered 20 courses, divided into 4 cups, 8 playable characters, and pseudo-3D Mode 7 graphics. The Mode 7 effect provided a rotation and scaling effect to flat 2D sprites that produced a 3D appearance without the need for actual polygon rendering. The power-up system was designed so that losing players could potentially catch up to winning players due to good fortune while skilled players could win due to their ability. Super Mario Kart recognised that the enjoyment of multiplayer was dependent upon having an element of accessibility along with the ability to express skill.
2. Mario Kart 64 (N64, 1996) – The Technical Revolution that took it Full 3-Dimensional
We are recognising that Mario Kart will appear twice on this list because the franchise is that important. Mario Kart 64 was released in Japan on December 14, 1996, in North America on February 10, 1997, and in Europe in June 1997. The N64 version was a fundamental change in thinking regarding what kart racing could be in a fully three dimensional environment.
The technical challenges associated with Mario Kart 64 were substantial. The N64 had a Hitachi/NEC VR4300 CPU that operated at 93.75 MHz with a Reality Co-Processor that handled graphics processing generating approximately 100,000 polygons per second. The N64 was significantly faster than the SNES, but it also implied that the game had to be designed using three dimensional polygon rendering as opposed to the two dimensional sprite scaling used in Super Mario Kart. The courses had to be redesigned in three dimensions. The physics had to accommodate a three dimensional environment as opposed to a flat course with visual trickery to simulate depth.
Mario Kart 64 sold 19.93 million units worldwide, making it the 2nd best-selling N64 game, behind Super Mario 64. Mario Kart 64 maintained four-player multiplayer while advancing to true three dimensional gameplay. Achieving true three dimensional multiplayer was a difficult task in terms of the hardware requirements.
Mario Kart 64 included 16 courses plus battle arenas, 8 vehicles, and operated at 25 frames per second with time trial and ghost data features. The addition of battle mode as a central part of the game introduced an additional form of multiplayer gaming beyond just racing one another. Time trials with ghost data allowed you to compete against your own times. The game realised that multiplayer racing requires options beyond just competing with one another.
Metacritic gave the game an 87/100 rating. EGM gave the game a 9.25/10 and praised the four-player three dimensional racing and battle mode innovations. While criticism about outdated controls was justified, the technical accomplishment and commercial success of Mario Kart 64 showed that three dimensional kart racing on console hardware was achievable.
Read why Joe thinks Mario Kart 64 is the greatest racing game of all time
3. Gran Turismo (PS1, 1997) – The Simulation Racer That Established Console Racing as Serious
Gran Turismo was released in Japan on December 23, 1997, in North America on April 30, 1998, and in Europe on May 8, 1998. This is the game that proved that console racing could be taken seriously. Prior to Gran Turismo, simulation racing was the province of PC enthusiasts who used expensive steering wheels to recreate the feeling of real-world racing. Gran Turismo brought authentic racing physics to a standard console controller and proved that console players desired authenticity as much as arcade fun.
Gran Turismo was an ambitious undertaking. The game included 140 vehicles, 11 courses with 36 varieties, five camera angles, and approximately 50 hours to attain 100% completion. Gran Turismo was not merely a racing game. It was a racing simulator with the depth of a career mode. You did not merely race. You advanced through difficulty levels, purchased and modified vehicles, and unlocked new content over dozens of hours.
Gran Turismo went on to sell 10.85 million units worldwide, making it the 2nd best-selling PS1 game, with 2.45 million in Japan and 6.14 million in North America. Gran Turismo’s commercial success proved that console players wanted depth and realism. The simulation racing audience was not limited to PC hobbyists. Console players would accept realistic physics and extensive career modes if given the opportunity.
IGN awarded Gran Turismo a perfect 10/10. Metacritic gave the game a 96/100 rating. These ratings reflect that Gran Turismo was not merely technologically impressive. It represented a complete rethinking of what console racing could be. The realistic physics engine, the large number of vehicles, the number and variety of tracks, and the career advancement all contributed to a game that felt like a comprehensive racing experience.
4. F-Zero (SNES, 1990) – The Future High-Speed Racing Experience
F-Zero was released in Japan on November 21, 1990, in North America in November 1990, and in Europe in September 1991. This is the game that proved that Mode 7 scaling was not a mere technical gimmick. It was a valid method for producing the sensation of speed on 16-bit hardware.
F-Zero utilised the same Mode 7 scaling effect as Super Mario Kart, but it was applied to a completely different type of game. Rather than being a casual kart racing game, F-Zero was a high-speed futuristic racing game in which the tracks twist and spiral in ways that would be geometrically impossible on a flat surface. The pseudo-3D effect made you feel as though you were flying through space at speeds that were physically impossible.
F-Zero sold approximately 2.9 million units, with estimated sales of 4.9 million with bundle versions. The game was bundled with many SNES consoles in North America which artificially inflated the sales figures, but the raw sales figure for the game were impressive. The game helped launch the SNES in North America and proved that the console was capable of delivering arcade quality experiences.
The game featured 5 teams, 3 difficulty levels, a 50-course Grand Prix mode, and simulated speeds of over 200 mph on screen. The speed of F-Zero was revolutionary. Previous racing games felt as though cars were travelling across a flat surface. F-Zero felt as though you were piloting a spacecraft at terminal velocity. The Mode 7 scaling made the track appear to be approaching and receding at extremely high speeds.
5. Road Rash (Genesis, 1991) – The Traffic Racer with Attitude
Road Rash was released in North America in September 1991 and was ported to numerous platforms, including Genesis, PC, Master System, Game Gear, 3DO, Saturn, and PS1. This is the game that demonstrated that racing games didn’t have to be circuit racing games. They could be about street racing through traffic with motorcycles and chain whip violence.
Road Rash was fundamentally different from every other game on this list. Rather than racing around a circuit, you raced through traffic on open roads. Rather than having access to power-ups, you had weapons: chain whips, kicks, and combinations of punches you could use against other racers. The game was chaotic in ways that traditional racing games were not.
The Genesis version of Road Rash sold approximately 1.5 million units, with the total sales for the Road Rash series exceeding 5 million units across all platforms. The commercial success of Road Rash demonstrated that consumers wanted variety in racing games. Road Rash demonstrated that racing games could be about more than just pure racing mechanics.
Road Rash featured 3 motorcycles, 5 routes throughout the western United States, and first, second, and third person views. The variety of viewing perspectives allowed players to select how they wished to experience the racing. The handling of the motorcycles differed from car racing. The violence system was unique and impacted the outcome of races. Players could win through speed, or by employing violent tactics against other racers.
6. Pole Position (Arcade/NES, 1982/83) – The Arcade Game That Created The Template For Racing Games
In June 1982 in Japan and the United States, Namco launched Pole Position, with NES ports arriving in 1983 and Europe in 1984. At the time of its release, there was no standard model for a racing game. With the release of Pole Position, this changed.
When the arcade version was released, it revolutionised the gaming industry. Not only did the game use a steering wheel controller, analog throttle and brake pedals, and a 3D first person view, but it also provided a fully immersive gaming experience. Players were seated inside an arcade cabinet that was designed to mimic the feel of being in a real car racing environment.
The arcade version of Pole Position went on to sell approximately 30,000 cabinets and became one of the top-selling arcade games of the early 1980s. The NES version of the game sold around 500,000 units; however, it suffered from slowdown issues that the original arcade version did not experience. The financial success of the arcade version of Pole Position demonstrated that gamers were willing to spend money on racing games and that they desired a form of racing entertainment.
Pole Position featured four tracks, a qualifying lap system, eight cars, and utilised a Namco arcade board. The qualifying lap system allowed players to practise on each track before entering a race against other drivers, providing a more challenging experience for players. The game was designed to provide a challenge to players by requiring them to master a specific track prior to racing against others.
7. OutRun (Arcade/Genesis, 1986/89) – The Convertible Dream That Established the Standard for Arcade Racing Design
OutRun was released in arcades in September 1986 in Japan and September 1987 in North America and Europe, with Genesis ports arriving in 1991. OutRun was the first racing game to focus on the fantasy of owning a convertible sports car and experiencing the thrill of driving along scenic coastlines with a beautiful passenger by your side.
The OutRun arcade cabinet was a work of art and helped establish the standards for arcade racing experience design. Each player sat in a cockpit that simulated the driver’s seat of a Ferrari Testarossa convertible sports car, and the cabin was equipped with a steering wheel, hydraulic motion control, and a stereo speaker system that produced an electronic music soundtrack. When combined, the design elements of the cabinet created a completely immersive gaming experience that captured the imagination of many gamers.
The arcade version of OutRun sold more than 20,000 cabinets and the Genesis version sold more than 1 million copies, with the total for the entire series estimated to exceed 15 million copies worldwide. The success of OutRun demonstrated that arcade racing experiences can extend beyond competition and become an extension of a gamer’s lifestyle. Gamers want to experience the thrill of driving a sports car, feeling free, and enjoying the open road.
OutRun featured 15 separate tracks, each with five primary route options, pseudo-3D scaling, and four possible ending results depending on the route choices you made during the race. Because OutRun used branching routes, it was both an exploratory and racing experience. The four possible endings provided additional incentive to play the game repeatedly in order to experience the variety of routes available to you.
8. Wipeout (PS1, 1995) – The Anti-Gravity Racing Experience That Demonstrated Consoles Could Handle Arcade-Style Racing
Released in Europe in September 1995 and in North America in November 1995, with a Japanese release in 1996, Wipeout was the first racing game to demonstrate the potential of consoles to deliver arcade-style racing experiences. Wipeout was fast-paced, stylish, and specifically designed to take advantage of the Sony PlayStation’s ability to render polygons quickly.
From a visual standpoint, Wipeout was revolutionary. The music featured songs by several electronic artists, such as The Chemical Brothers and The Prodigy. The visuals were futuristic and clean. Unlike many racing games at the time, Wipeout focused on creating a futuristic racing experience rather than simulating reality.
Wipeout sold 1.5 million units on the PlayStation console and the overall franchise exceeded 10 million units worldwide. The commercial success of Wipeout demonstrated that console gamers desire racing games that are as exciting as arcade-style racing games, but with a focus on artistic expression.
Wipeout featured four playable ships, eight tracks, three weapon systems, was capable of running at more than 50 frames per second, and had a techno soundtrack that was integral to the gaming experience. The addition of a weapon system made Wipeout more than a pure racing experience, as you needed to manage shields, pick up power-ups, and engage in combat tactics while racing at extremely high speeds.
9. Daytona USA (Arcade/Genesis, 1993/96) – The Stock Car Racing Title That Transferred the Arcade Experience to Home Consoles
Releasing as an arcade title in 1993 and in Japan in March 1994, and as a Sega Genesis title in 1996, Daytona USA was the first arcade racing title to successfully transfer the arcade experience to home consoles. As an arcade title, Daytona USA was an instant hit, and when it transferred to the Genesis console, it delivered that same experience to the homes of thousands of gamers.
Technically, the arcade version of Daytona USA was impressive. It displayed 60 FPS with hydraulic motion, allowed up to eight players to link arcade cabinets for multiplayer racing, and provided an incredibly immersive and competitive gaming experience.
While the arcade version of Daytona USA sold over 10,000 cabinets, the Genesis version sold approximately 500,000 units, and Saturn versions sold 1 million units. The commercial success across multiple platforms demonstrated that Daytona USA was appealing to a wide audience that extended far beyond die-hard arcade fans. Thousands of home console players were looking for authentic arcade racing experiences.
Daytona USA featured three tracks, three different camera views, stock cars, and achieved 60 FPS in the arcade version. Although the Genesis port of Daytona USA was less visually impressive than the arcade version, the underlying racing experience remained the same. Daytona USA knew that home ports of arcade titles had to make sacrifices, but that those sacrifices could still produce a fun gaming experience.
10. Cruisin’ USA (Arcade/N64, 1994/96) – The Arcade Road Trip Title That Introduced Iconic Landmarks into a Racing Experience
First appearing in arcades in 1994, and on the Nintendo 64 in North America in 1996, and in Europe in 1997, Cruisin’ USA was the first racing title to combine exploration and sightseeing with the traditional racing experience. Cruisin’ USA took gamers on a road trip across America, racing through famous and iconic landmarks and locations.
Similar to the arcade version of Daytona USA, the arcade version of Cruisin’ USA featured hydraulic motion controls and a steering wheel interface, providing an immersive gaming experience to arcade patrons. The Nintendo 64 port of Cruisin’ USA attempted to bring the essence of that arcade experience to home consoles.
The Nintendo 64 version of Cruisin’ USA sold approximately 1.4 million units. The commercial success of Cruisin’ USA demonstrated that console gamers were interested in arcade-style racing experiences that were based on exploration and tourism as well as competition.
Cruisin’ USA featured seven tracks that represented real US roads, four vehicles, two-player simultaneous racing, and several types of power-ups that affected gameplay. The fact that Cruisin’ USA featured real world locations lent itself to a greater sense of place than typical circuit racing titles. Cruisin’ USA was more than a racing title, it was a virtual road trip across America.
The Evolution of Racing Games: What We Learned
Collectively, these ten titles represent the technological advancements and commercial successes that defined the development of racing games throughout the 1980s and 1990s. Collectively, we observe the transition from vector-based graphics in the early arcade titles to 2D sprites and eventually to full 3D polygon rendering. Collectively, we observe the shift from pure racing simulations to arcade fantasies to lifestyle experiences.
What all of these titles share is the recognition of their hardware and the willingness to push it farther than anyone ever believed possible. None of these titles simply sought to add “faster cars” to “faster hardware.” Instead, they recognised that racing games could offer a variety of experiences: competition, fantasy, style, exploration, and/or combat.
The 1980s and 1990s were the golden years of racing games because the rapid advancement of console hardware allowed developers to develop fundamentally new forms of game design with each successive generation of hardware. A title that was technologically impressive in 1990 appeared primitive by 1995. A title that was commercially successful in 1992 was rendered obsolete by something newer and better by 1997.
Collectively, these ten titles stand above the rest of the genre. Collectively, they serve as examples of how racing games can transcend the technology of their time. Collectively, they created templates for other developers to follow. Collectively, they demonstrated that racing games could be commercially successful on multiple platforms, including arcade machines, consoles, and personal computers. Collectively, these titles are why the 1980s and 1990s will always be considered the golden years of racing games.
Joe’s a history teacher who treats the console wars like actual history. A lifelong Sega devotee from Phoenix, he writes with passion, humor, and lingering heartbreak over the Dreamcast. Expect strong opinions, bad puns, and plenty of “blast processing.”
0 Comments