I learned that success in the console war is not just about having the best software — sometimes the best software is on the wrong hardware at the wrong time and nobody will remember it. Although Sony’s PlayStation was the dominant platform for JRPGs, due to the fact that Final Fantasy VII, VIII, and IX were available for purchase on PlayStation; Sega demonstrated a clear understanding of how to develop JRPGs just as well, by developing and releasing the JRPG “Skies of Arcadia” on the Dreamcast.
Since I am a history teacher, I appreciate both context and consequences. “Skies of Arcadia” had all the elements necessary to be remembered alongside the other great JRPGs developed for PlayStation, including that it shipped during the exact period when the Dreamcast was dying and therefore instead of celebrating its release, it became a footnote in the annals of gaming history.
What Skies of Arcadia Really Is
You play the role of a sky pirate in a world where the continents float in the sky and airships are the primary mode of transportation. Instead of fighting to save the world from impending doom, you are simply trying to survive as a pirate, find treasure, and slowly discover that your adversaries have far greater ambitions. While the game is playful and serious in a manner that feels very unique, it is not overly complex.
The story is straightforward, however the delivery is endearing. Your party members have individual personalities. The world has been fleshed out. The supporting characters are interesting. The dialogue is full of personality without being annoying. You interact with characters that you have come to care about rather than simply interacting with the plot vehicle.
The turn based combat is average, but not particularly new. You select actions, use special abilities, manage resources. The difficulty curve is reasonable. Boss battles require strategy over grinding. The progression feels earned. This is respectable JRPG design that appreciates the player’s investment of time.
The ability to command and fight with airships adds variety to the traditional battle system. You control an airship versus enemy vessels. Manage your crew. Decide on strategies. The airship combat is truly enjoyable and serves as a nice break from the standard battles.
Why Skies of Arcadia Matters For Understanding Sega’s Software
Here is what people forget — Sega could also produce excellent JRPGs. Final Fantasy belonged to Square. Dragon Quest belonged to Square-Enix. However, Sega produced its own JRPG identity in Skies of Arcadia, Grandia II, Phantasy Star Online, etc. and that identity was competitive.
However, Sega lacked the third party support of the PlayStation’s JRPG library. Many developers (Square and many others) chose to support the PlayStation since that is where the market was. The quantity of software available on the PlayStation ultimately mattered, not the quality of the software.
This is an important lesson in terms of history. The best software does not necessarily mean success in the market. Positioning in the market, third party support, timing, and luck greatly influence success in the market. Skies of Arcadia exemplifies this — it is an extremely high quality JRPG and nearly no one can recall it due to the fact that it was released on the Dreamcast at a time when the Dreamcast was already doomed to fail.
The Feel of the Genuine World Design
The world of Skies of Arcadia is meticulously designed. The sky pirate theme is relatively original — most RPG worlds use either medieval fantasy or science fiction. Skies uses airships and floating continents and pirates. While it may seem similar to some of the other fantasy worlds we know, the differences are significant enough to be perceived as new.
Each person you meet in the game is unique and intriguing. Each twist in the plot is justified and not arbitrary. Each piece of information regarding each member of your party is provided through experience and interaction with those individuals, rather than through expository means.
While the side quests are completely optional, they are interesting enough to encourage exploration. They do not provide unnecessary padding for the main quest, but are rather individualised stories and background for the world.
The Technical Achievement
The graphics for Skies of Arcadia are quaint, yet clearly old-fashioned. The character models are detailed. The animation is smooth. The magical effects are visually impressive. The environments contribute to creating atmosphere. The overall presentation is clean and easy to read, without attempting to create photorealism.
The voice acting is professional. The soundtrack composed by Kazunari Tomi and several others is superior — memorable, yet unobtrusive. The sound design effectively contributes to creating atmosphere, providing the impression that you are in a world of floating continents and sky pirates.
The game is extensive — 40+ hours of gameplay, depending on how engaged you are in the game content. The amount of time required to complete the game is not padding — it represents genuine content worthy of the player’s attention. The pacing is effective. The story unfolds appropriately. The development of the characters feels authentic.
Is Skies of Arcadia Still Worth Playing Today?
Yes — the turn based combat has not grown old. The development of the characters is still entertaining. The world remains charming. The story is still enjoyable. The pacing is still good. When playing this today, the only thing that seems dated is the graphical quality. However, the visual style is strong enough to help you ignore the dated graphics.
The difficulty level is perfectly balanced. The difficulty is low enough so you will rarely get stuck on a boss fight multiple times. The difficulty is high enough that you will have to actively think about the combat system rather than simply pressing the attack button repeatedly. The progression through the game feels rewarding.
The inclusion of ship combat provides additional variety to the standard battle system. Ship combat is an excellent addition, providing an adequate break from the standard battles. The strategic aspect of determining which members of your crew to take into battle creates actual player agency.
Why This Game Was Important Historically
Skies of Arcadia represented an important aspect of Sega’s software capabilities while their hardware was dying. The game demonstrates that even though Sega’s hardware sales were declining, Sega was capable of producing software that was equally competitive to the PlayStation JRPGs. Had Skies of Arcadia been released on the PlayStation, it would likely be remembered as one of the top JRPGs available on the PlayStation. Since it was released on the Dreamcast, it was relegated to being a footnote in gaming history. The reason for this has nothing to do with the quality of the game itself, and everything to do with the market position and timing of the game.
Conclusion
Skies of Arcadia is a JRPG that demonstrates that Sega understood how to develop excellent JRPGs. The world of the game is charming. The characters are interesting. The story is entertaining. The combat is adequate. The pacing of the game is perfect. The game offers a lot of scope.
This game should be remembered as evidence that the Dreamcast had sufficient quality software to compete with the PlayStation, even though the Dreamcast failed commercially. If you have not played it, go seek it out and learn why Sega’s Dreamcast library deserves recognition despite the commercial failure of the console.
Rating: 9/10 — The JRPG that demonstrates that quality software does not equate to successful marketing
Return to our full Dreamcast rankings →
Joe’s a history teacher who treats the console wars like actual history. A lifelong Sega devotee from Phoenix, he writes with passion, humor, and lingering heartbreak over the Dreamcast. Expect strong opinions, bad puns, and plenty of “blast processing.”
0 Comments